In Wills & Estates

Prenuptial agreements, also known as marriage contracts, have gained significant traction in Canada since the 1978 Family Law Reform Act. This act explicitly authorized their use and provided a legal framework for their enforcement in courts. Prior to this act, such powers of attorney and representation agreements held no legal weight.

A study by the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers shows a growing number of millennials are choosing to get prenuptial agreements. A survey revealed that 51% of AAML attorneys reported increased requests for prenups, specifically from millennials. 62% of respondents noted a general increase in prenuptial agreements across their client base over the past three years.

In this blog, witness how a wills attorney explains prenuptial agreements, simple wills and financial security and how they will assist you through the process.

Primary Reasons for Creating a Prenuptial Agreement

While sometimes viewed with suspicion, prenuptial agreements serve practicality to enhance a marriage’s financial security.

Protecting Premarital Assets

Prenuptial agreements are commonly used to shield premarital assets, especially for those marrying later in life with careers, inheritances, or family businesses. The prenup clarifies these assets as separate property to ensure they remain with the owning spouse in the event of a divorce.

Safeguarding Inheritances (Patients Property Act)

Prenups classify inheritances, such as estate or business of the owning spouse, as separate property to safeguard joint ownership between them. This ensures they pass to the inheriting spouse in a divorce, avoiding division and potential conflict.

Clarity for Family Businesses (Family Members)

Prenuptial agreements guarantee the business remains the owner spouse’s separate property while potentially allowing spousal access to profits without affecting ownership.

Managing Debt (Pre-Marital and Future)

Prenuptial agreements can address both existing and future debt. They clarify pre-marital debt ownership (student loans etc.) for beneficiaries and prevent future commingling through separate accounts or designated debt repayment plans.

Clarifying Spousal Support (Alimony)

Prenuptial agreements can define spousal support (alimony) terms in a divorce. This benefits couples with unequal earning potential or where one spouse prioritizes childcare, ensuring predictable financial arrangements after a separation.

Considering Estate Plan

Prenuptial agreements can integrate with an estate plan, especially for those with prior children or inheritance concerns. By enduring a power of attorney and outlining how inheritances and trusts are handled in a divorce to an estate administration, prenups align with estate plans, minimize legal disputes, and uphold the testator’s wishes.

Legal Requirements for Prenuptial Agreements in Canada

For a prenuptial agreement (also known as a marriage contract) to be enforceable in Canada, it must adhere to specific legal requirements:

Full Disclosure (Financial Transparency)

Both parties are obligated to fully and frankly disclose their financial situation to an estate administration. This includes complete disclosure of assets, liabilities, and income sources. Material omissions or misrepresentations can render the prenup unenforceable.

Voluntary Consent (Free Will)

The agreement must be signed willingly and without any form of coercion or undue influence. Pressure or threats to manipulate one party into signing can invalidate the prenup.

Independent Legal Advice (Separate Counsel)

While not mandatory, it is advised that each party seek independent lawyer from a defence attorney backed by family law. This ensures each party understands the legal implications of the representation agreement and has the opportunity to negotiate terms fairly.

Fairness and Reasonableness (Balancing Interests and Probate Fees)

A court must consider the circumstances at the time of signing to determine whether the prenup terms are fair and reasonable.

Formalization in Writing (Following Estate Planning Documents)

The prenuptial agreement must be a manuscript and meet specific requirements of the estate administration regarding format and witness signatures. Consult with estate planning lawyers familiar with the legalities in your specific province to ensure the representation agreement is enforceable.

Typical Provisions Included in a Prenuptial Agreement

  • Division of Assets: This clarifies premarital assets (inheritance, business, estate, etc.) as separate property to ensure they remain with the owning spouse after a divorce–separate from marital assets subject to division.
  • Marital Property: Prenuptial agreements can define how marital property (assets, debts acquired during the marriage, estates of joint tenancy) is divided in a divorce.
  • Spousal Support (Alimony) Arrangements: This benefits couples with unequal earning potential or those prioritizing childcare, ensuring predictable financial arrangements post-separation.
  • Debt Management Responsibilities: Prenuptial agreements can clarify pre-marital debt ownership and future debt management strategies. This promotes financial transparency, avoids future debt disputes, and protects each spouse’s financial affairs and obligations.
  • Inheritance Rights (Waivers or Limitations): This is useful for couples with prior children, specific inheritance plans, or complicated wills. The agreement can waive a spouse’s inheritance rights from marital assets or limit their inheritance amount, ensuring alignment with the estates’ plans and minimizing disputes after a divorce.

Estate Administration Process for a Prenuptial Agreement

A prenuptial agreement requires a well-defined negotiation process to ensure fairness, clarity, and enforceability. Here are the steps:

  1. Open Communication and Transparency
  2. Early Disclosure of Financial Information
  3. Seeking Professional Legal Guidance (Separate Counsel)
  4. Negotiation and Drafting Strategies
  5. Review and Finalization
  6. Signing and Witnessing

Changes in Circumstances and Revisiting the Prenup Through Wills Attorney

While prenuptial agreements offer stability, life throws curveballs. Significant events can necessitate revisiting the agreement to ensure it remains fair and enforceable.

Significant Life Events

Significant life events (children, inheritances, career shifts) can alter a couple’s financial landscape. Revisiting the prenup through a wills attorney in such cases ensures it reflects existing power and protects both spouses’ interests and probate applications, other family members, particularly any children, and avoids any more complicated wills.
Process for Amending a Prenup Amending a prenup mirrors the initial process. It requires full financial disclosure of substantial assets from both spouses, separate lawyers for each to assist clients, and a written amendment following the same legal formalities as the original prenup for further assistance.

Real-Life Cases

Jennifer Lynne Dundas v. Arthur Melvin Schafer

This case highlights the potential challenges of prenups and changing circumstances in a family’s future.  

Ms. Dundas signed a prenup waiving her rights to Mr. Schafer’s pension. Following their divorce, she challenged the prenup’s validity due to changed financial circumstances. The courts ultimately upheld the prenup’s core provision (pension waiver) but removed an unrelated financial penalty from the agreement. 

The Dr. Dre and Nicole Young Case 

This exemplifies the difficulty of revising a prenup based on alleged changes in circumstance from a loved one. 

Young claims coercion during the signing (1996). But her assertion that Dr. Dre later tore up copies likely holds no legal weight in a court order. Courts generally favour upholding prenups meeting legal requirements at signing. 

Amending a prenup requires a documented process or enduring power of attorney with independent legal counsel, not a symbolic gesture of tearing up documents. This case serves as a reminder for couples to plan ahead and prioritize fair prenup negotiation while considering the potential need for representation agreement, and future revisions due to life events.

State Laws in Canada Relevant to Prenuptial Agreements

While prenuptial agreements are recognized across Canada, legal variations can vary by province and territory.

Provincial Variations

British Columbia The Family Law Act emphasizes the importance of full disclosure and independent legal advice for enforceability.
Ontario The Courts of Justice Act allows courts to consider the litigation circumstances under which the prenup was made when determining its validity.
Quebec Civil law principles apply, representation agreements and prenuptial agreements have different formalities and considerations compared to common law provinces and their legal services. 

 

 

Recognize the Enduring Power of Prenuptial Agreements to Your Future

As seen in real-life cases, prenups can protect assets, ensure fairness in the event of separation, and even evolve alongside your relationship. It is important to seek the right person to assist you in navigating the prenup process and ensure your representation agreement is clear, your wills and estate plan are enforceable, and your future finances are protected. Contact Sidhu Legal today for a detailed consultation and other legal services regarding wills and estate planning. 

 

Frequently Asked Questions

My fiancé and I are getting married in Quebec. Do the same prenup rules apply to other provinces in Canada?

No, Quebec operates under a civil law system, and prenuptial agreements are called marriage contracts.  These contracts have different formalities and considerations compared to common law provinces.  In Quebec, a notary public must oversee the drafting and signing of the marriage contract, and specific rules govern what can and cannot be included in the agreement. Consulting a Quebec civil law notary specializing in family law is crucial before entering into a marriage contract.

Our prenup was fair when we signed it 10 years ago, but we recently had twins. Does the prenup still hold up?

The arrival of children can be a significant life event that alters the financial landscape of a marriage.  While your original prenup may still be enforceable, it’s wise to revisit it with a lawyer.  Lawyers advise clients whether amendments are necessary to ensure the representation agreement reflects your current financial circumstances and protects the interests of both you and your children. The amendment process typically involves full financial disclosure again, other important documents, and independent lawyers for each spouse.

My spouse and I tore up our prenup in a fit of anger a few years ago. Is it still valid?

Simply tearing up a prenup doesn’t necessarily negate its validity.  Courts and estate lawyers generally look for formal written estate documents demonstrating the intention to revoke the agreement.  However, the act of tearing it up, along with any surrounding circumstances, could be factors considered by a judge in determining the prenup’s enforceability. If you and your spouse no longer want the prenup to apply, it’s best to consult wills and estate lawyers to draft a formal written revocation document.

Recent Posts
Contact Us

We're not around right now. But you can send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

Not readable? Change text. captcha txt